Socially Responsible Investing: Part I- Where Do I Begin?

I’ve been thinking about converting at least part of my 401k to socially responsible investments (SRI) for a while. But where do I begin? How do I go about finding the best investments for me? Can I also do it with my very small non-401k portfolio?
In this series, I hope to answer these questions. I’m also hoping to hear from you readers. How are you approaching this? Is anyone else out there feeling as guilty as I am that they haven’t done this already?
Here’s my progress so far:
Initially, I had to get over a few roadblocks:
My 401K currently doesn’t offer SRI funds.
Solution: I can divert my non-company matched contributions to alternate retirement vehicles.
I’m 49 years old, and hope to retire in this lifetime. Is that possible with SRI? I’ve heard their performance is lower and their fees are higher.
Solution: I’m hoping compromise won’t be necessary as the world becomes more socially and environmentally conscious. But I am nervous. I realize I’m extremely hesitant to compromise a comfortable retirement. I’ll be quite cautious as I make my portfolio conversion. I’ve also made an appointment with a financial planner for the end of March. I want to have all my ducks in a row. I only get one shot at saving for retirement. And my clock is ticking.
Once I got over these hurdles, I started implementing my plan:
1) I’ve started a list of social and environmental issues that are important to me. Here’s my list so far:
Environmental
Global warming
Protection of open space
Sustainable environmental practice
Social
Fair Trade
Fair Labor Policy
Support of liberal social positions such as social diversity and government supported medical care
Healthy global economics and development
Community investing
World peace
Animal rights
Depending on what prospective investments I come across, I may add to this list.
2) Determine just how socially and/or environmentally responsible the company needs to be to meet my criteria.For example, Microsoft is considered a “Green” stock by many SRI mutual funds. It is green not for what it produces, but because it practices business in an environmentally responsible manner.
After much thought, I decided to do this aspect of the analysis on a case by case basis. For example, I might be able to let some things go if a company has made recent strides in the right direction.
3) Do research.
This is my next step. I’ve tracked down some research tools I’ll use in my screening process.
Tools
Social Investment Forum.
Social Funds
Co-op America
CDFI- Coalition of Community Development Financial Institutions
Calvert Group
Other Reading
Green Money Journal
Top Five Social Investing News Articles of 2007
PRI- Principles for Responsible Investment
Stay tuned for Part II of this series. I’ll report back on what I’ve found out from my screening research. I’ll also discuss how I’ll incorporate these SRI stocks/ETFs into Jason Kelly’s worksheet for choosing healthy stocks. For an introduction to the worksheet, see my eighth installment of the “Beginning Investments 101” series. It will be out next week.
| 2.5 |
Comment by
Pinyo (Who am I?) on 30 May 2008:
With all due respect, and I really mean it. I am not an advocate of SRI investing. If I want to be socially/environmentally responsible, I think I am better off with a more flexible investing plan (i.e., not restricted by SRI) and then commit an amount to the organization(s) that contribute to improving these issues.
Pinyos last blog post..Why living cheap is more important than investing
Comment by
Lisa (Who am I?) on 30 May 2008:
@ Pinyo- I agree, it is an option ,but I am too close to retirement to risk going into specific SRIs. Luckily, my regular funds (see Post II) are pretty SRI anyway. On the Target Retirement Funds- You’re funny! - Thanks for the comments - L